22 Engaging The Midnight Library Book Club Questions

Are you reading The Midnight Library by Matt Haig as part of your book club this month and you want to go in armed with some insightful questions? Well, you’ve come to the right place!

We’ve compiled a list of book club questions for The Midnight Library so you can start an engaging conversation about the novel with your book club members.

Of course, when discussing books at a book club, often organic questions come up based on what people have to say, so use these The Midnight Library Book Club Questions as a guide to get you started and to inspire the conversation should it be dwindling.

Also to make your life easier, we’ve prepared a list of suggestions for what to read next, so you can offer some suggestions for the next read.

Left it too late to plan your book club meeting? Don’t worry, we have your back…


The Midnight Library is a multi-award-winning novel by Matt Haig about a woman who suffers from low mental health, and gets to see what life would be like had she made different choices in the past.

I loved this book so much and highly recommend it to anyone that might underestimate the importance of thinking on the bright side of life, and appreciating what you have.

When the protagonist Nora decides to end her life, she is taken to a place called The Midnight Library where she can choose a book, which has thousands of books about her life but with one thing different. As she begins to read each book, she sees a different future each time. Each is beautiful and terrible in its own way…

This is a deep and meaningful book on a touchy subject, but Haig has written it with sincerity and deep emotion.

It won the best Fiction Award at the Goodreads Choice Awards in 2020.

Spoiler Alert! 

Please note that the questions below contain spoilers of the book.

Generic Book Club Questions for The Midnight Library

Let’s begin the list with some generic questions to get the ball rolling. These questions about The Midnight Library are designed to encourage every member of your group to say something about the book.

Perhaps you have a shy member of the group or a newbie? These will help give them the confidence to speak up.

  • What did you think about the book? (obvious, but we have to say it).
  • What were your expectations before reading The Midnight Library?
  • How did The Midnight Library make you feel?
  • What would you do if you ended up in The Midnight Library? How would you handle it?
  • Which was the most interesting alternate reality in the book, in your opinion?
  • Were there any characters that you felt an affinity to? Could you relate in any way?
  • What do you think happens to Nora going forward? What’s next?
  • What are the key principles you have learned from the book? What have you taken away from the story?

The Midnight Library Discussion Questions

Once you’ve gone through the general chit chat, it’s time to open up a deeper and more meaningful discussion. Here are book club discussion questions for The Midnight Library we recommend you bring up…

  • How did you feel once you finished?
  • Why do you think it was so important for Nara to enter a library?
  • Did this story make you feel differently about your own life? Why or why not?
  • Why do you think Nora felt she had no other choice but to end her life? What pushed her over the edge, do you think?
  • Mrs. Elm gives Nora the chance to undo her regrets. If you could undo your regrets, would you?
  • Mrs. Elm was there when Nora’s mom passed away, but after school, she doesn’t have much to do with her life. Do you think Mrs. Elm had a big impact on Nora’s life?
  • Why do you think Nora blamed everyone else for her unhappiness? How did this lead to her downfall?
  • What do you think makes for a fulfilling life?

Educated Book Club Questions for The Midnight Library

Want to dive deeper into the philosophy and hidden messages of the book? Then you’re going to want to ask some of these educated The Midnight Library Book Club questions…

  • Let’s discuss Nora’s family. What did you think of her relationship with her brother? Do you think she was self-sabotaging the relationship?
  • Why do you think Nora saw her former school librarian? What was the significance there?
  • What do you think Matt Haig meant when he wrote: “Want,’ she told her, in a measured tone, ‘is an interesting word. It means lack. Sometimes if we fill that lack with something else the original want disappears entirely.”
  • When do you think Nora decided she really wanted to live?
  • One of the major themes of this novel is regret. Do you think that regret hangs around with you forever, as Matt Haig illudes to in this book, or do you think we can get over our regrets?
  • Let’s talk about how Nora’s character progresses throughout the book. What are the biggest lessons she learns?

5 Suggestions for What to Read Next

Now you have a list of questions to discuss at your book club meeting, it’s time to plan the next one. Here are some suggestions for books to read next.

If your book club are looking for affordable ways to read more books, you’ll find some of these titles on Kindle Unlimited

1. The Shadow of the Wind – Carlos Ruiz Zafón

Shadow of the Wind is the first book in a series (The Cemetery of Lost Books) of four books set in Barcelona, however, the first book has a concluding story so you don’t have to read the remainder of the series.

It follows a young boy named Daniel and his coming-of-age journey. After his mother passes, his father takes him to a place known as the Cemetery of Lost Books where he is told he can pick one book to take home.

He picks up a book by Julian Carax called ‘The Shadow of the Wind.’ It’s the most beautiful book he has ever read, and he treasures it for many years.

When one day he decides to find other books by the author, he learns that someone is trying to destroy all of Julian Carax’s work.

Determined to stop this from happening, and to learn more about the author, Daniel seeks to track down the author. Only doing so unravels more mysteries to solve…

2. The Invisible Life of Addie Larue – V.E. Shwab

The Invisible Life of Addie Larue is about a young girl who is not satisfied with the idea of dying and being forgotten.

When given the opportunity to live forever, she takes it, knowing that it would mean everyone she knows and loves would perish and she will live on alone.

300 years passed, and all is well until she meets a man from her past in a bookshop. All is about to change…

The Invisible Life of Addie Larue explores concepts of death, remembrance and love. It’s gorgeously and poetically written and is full of thought-provoking messages.

If you’re looking for a book similar to Shadow of the Wind that’s captivating and songful, then you’re going to love this book.

Read more: Giver of Stars book club questions...

3. A Man Called Ove – Fredrik Backman

This book follows the story of Ove, a grumpy old man that the neighborhood has deemed “the bitter neighbor from hell”. However, there’s a lot more under the surface of Ove’s mean exterior.

Ove hasn’t had the best experiences with people. He has been conned and taken advantage of by people in the past. The only person he cared for, his wife, lost her life in a tragic accident.

These experiences have led to Ove having a hard shell and coming across as a curmudgeon to everyone in his neighborhood.

It’s not until a new family moves in next door and an unkempt cat enters his life that a different side of the man is revealed.

This popular best-seller was made into a Swedish movie in 2015. A Man Called Ove has also inspired an American movie titled A Man Called Otto. It’s set to release on Christmas Day in 2022 and stars Tom Hanks as Otto.

Read more: book club questions for A Man Called Ove

4. The 100 Year Old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared – Jonas Jonasson

Every once in a while books like A Man Called Ove comes out and find a permanent spot in the reader’s heart. 

The 100 Year Old Man Who Climbed Out The Window and Disappeared by Janos Jonasson is one of them. 

When Allan Karlsson is placed in a nursing home, he doesn’t agree with the decision and makes his own escape through the window in his slippers.

Allan goes on a journey that will have you laughing as you turn the pages. He meets a variety of new characters and reflects on the life he had.

5. The Silent Patient – Alex Michaelides

One of the most compelling books similar to A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder is The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides.

It seemed like Alicia Berenson had a perfect life. She was a famous painter who was married to one of the city’s most influential photographers.

They lived together in a beautiful house in one of the nicest neighborhoods in London. Everything was perfect, from the outside.

When Alicia’s husband returns home from work one night, she shoots him 5 times. After that, she doesn’t speak another word. Alicia’s act became one of the biggest mysteries in London.

Psychotherapist Theo Faber is determined to find out the truth about that night, eventually becoming obsessed with uncovering the answers to this mystery.

Read more: The Vanishing Half book club questions…

Final Word on The Midnight Library Book Club Questions

So there you have it, those were the best book club questions on The Midnight Library. I hope that these helped you start and drive the conversation at your next meeting.

If you had any interesting questions come up about this book, let us know in the comments! We’d love to hear from you.

Disclaimer: This website uses affiliate links, meaning I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through a link at no extra cost to you.

About Louisa

Editor/Founder - Epic Book Society

Louisa is the founder, editor, and head honcho of Epic Book Society. Once a published poet at the age of 7, she aspired to become a journalist, but that career hit a wall so here she is writing about books instead. When she's not writing about books, she's teaching English to primary school kids around the world.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.